What can Hifi learn from PA? (Pt.3)

Intro

Thanks for visiting the CODE Acoustics blog! If you’ve not heard of us, we’re a little company making high end domestic speakers in Woking, England (like the ones below).

_PH_1010

and I’m the founder and chief designer, Ceri Thomas:

me small

This blog series started after I visited Glastonbury Festival in 2017. There were many average sounding PA systems, but one or two very good ones. So I wanted to ask the basic question … ‘What can Hifi learn from PA?’.

IMG_1257

Part one of the series looked at a couple of the best (IMO) PA sound systems at the festival:

https://code-acoustics.blog/2017/06/30/glasto-2017-what-can-hifi-learn-from-pa-pt1/

Part two took a closer look at horn technology:

https://code-acoustics.blog/2017/07/23/glasto-2017-what-can-hifi-learn-from-pa-pt2/

In part three we’ll focus our attention on drive units (that’s the thing below if you weren’t sure!):

12LW1400

The basics

I’m going to skim this pretty quickly as there is a lot of info already on the web covering this. Here is a good page if you want to dive a little deeper:

https://www.ht-audio.com/pages/SpeakerBasics.html

Essentially an electrical signal (current) from the amplifier is passed through the voice coil of the drive unit. When this happens the voice coil becomes an ‘electromagnet’ and it’s magnetic field interacts with that of the permanent magnet:

Image result for speaker drive unit diagram

The principle is exactly the same as when you were a child and tried to push two magnets together:

Image result for magnet attract and repel

The permanent magnet cannot move, but the electromagnet (voice coil) can. As the voice coil moves, it also moves the cone (they’re physically connected) and hey presto you have a pressure wave (sound).

Sensitivity vs. Efficiency

Before we get to the meaty part where we compare Hifi and PA drive units, It’s important to explain these two terms.

Both describe how effectively the drive unit can convert electrical energy into acoustic energy (sound).

Here is a small hifi speaker that probably has a sensitivity around 82dB for 1 watt input, measured at 1 meter, or 0.1% efficiency:

1

In contrast a PA speaker may have a sensitivity of 99db for 1 watt at 1 meter or 5% efficiency! Yes that’s 50 times more efficient than the Hifi speaker!

Sensitivity is how much sound output you get in decibels (dB) when you apply a 1 watt signal and measure at 1m. The problem is manufacturers often don’t follow a standard test procedure, so it’s very hard to compare data.

Reference efficiency is simply what percentage of input energy is translated into output energy in free air:

2

This can’t be fudged and is a far more accurate means of comparison.

If you want to have a play here is a reference efficiency calculator:

https://www.ajdesigner.com/phpsubwooferclosed/reference_efficiency_equation.php#ajscroll

How are PA and Hifi drive units different?

To explain this I’ve picked two 6″ midrange drive units.

The Hifi driver is the very competent (and expensive!) Morel TSCM634:

Morel TSCM634 6" Titanium Supreme Carbon-Fiber Midrange

https://www.morelhifi.com/product/tscm-634/

The PA driver is a slightly more reasonably priced, but still very well made 18 Sound 6NMB420:

6NMB420

http://www.eighteensound.com/Products/Articles/catid/4050/eid/3407/6nmb420

The comparison

6NMB420 TSCM634
Mms (g) 8.5 15.3
Sd (cms) 130 119
Qes 0.38 0.56
Fs (Hz) 110 49
Bl (Tm.) 9 5.09
Vas (l) 6.1 13.3
Power Handling (w.) 200 150
Ref Eff (%) 2.03 0.27
EBP 289.5 87.5

There isn’t time to explain all the terms here, so if you’re not familiar with some or all of them, please have a look here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thiele/Small_parameters

What you can see is the Hifi driver has almost twice the moving mass of the PA driver (mms) and a motor that is almost half as powerful (Bl). This translates to widely different efficiencies. The PA drive unit is 7.5 times as efficient as the Hifi drive unit!

The plots

Below is a simple comparison of the the two drivers in a 20 litre reflex enclosure tuned at 40Hz in free space*.

*If you’re not sure what ‘free space’ is, there’s a section about it in Pt.2 of this series.

PLOT1

Red is the Hifi driver and white is the PA driver. Note that we’ve standardised the sensitivities for easier comparison.

It’s clear to see that the Hifi driver gives a lovely flat response in this box, yet the PA driver gives far less output as the frequency drops.

To get an even response for the PA driver, it requires a smaller box (3 litres) and a higher tuning frequency (130Hz).

PLOT2

 

Essentially the Hifi driver has a wider operating frequency band, or ‘window’ of frequency linearity.

*an octave is a doubling of frequency, so it could be 40-80Hz, 1000-2000Hz, 7500-15000Hz etc.

The graph below is the same plot as above, but this time showing the relative sound output achieved when each driver is fed 50 watts:

PLOT3

As you can see, the PA drive unit is giving an added 10dB over it’s operating band. This also means it’ll put significantly less strain on the amplifier to achieve a given volume.

The final graph shows you drive unit excursion in mm’s for the 50 watts input:

PLOT4

Despite the PA driver playing 10dB louder, it still hasn’t run out of x-max (linear travel) in it’s operating band. Whereas the Hifi driver is exceeding it’s x-max at 60Hz. However, it is worth noting, this is directly attributed to running the Hifi driver lower than the PA driver.

EBP

The usable frequency range of a drive unit can also be described by the parameter Efficiency Bandwidth Product (EBP), and is determined by dividing Fs by Qes.

It has traditionally been used to advise whether a drive unit should go in a reflex or sealed box:

Image result for speaker efficiency bandwidth product

Essentially a very high EBP will indicate the drive unit is highly efficient over a small bandwidth. A lower EBP will be less efficient, but have constant efficiency over a wider bandwidth.

The PA driver here has an EBP of 289.5 vs. 87.5 for the Hifi driver.

A very high EBP would also indicate a drive unit would work well in a horn.

The Caveats

I will have to do separate blogs on drive unit damping, thermal management and dispersion, as they’re big areas that warrant special attention.

There is also an argument to have about drive unit Max SPL and whether it’s acceptable to push them beyond their x-max. I’d argue no (from a technical point of view), but it depends what your priorities are.

Image result for speaker x-max

Conclusion

This blog hasn’t tried to answer the question of whether Hifi or PA drivers are ‘better’. It’s purpose is simply to demonstrate that they exhibit different behaviours:

  • A PA driver will give you higher sensitivity and max output, yet with a smaller window of frequency linearity.
  • A Hifi driver will give you lower sensitivity and max output, yet with a wider window of frequency linearity.

However, stay tuned as our Big Evolving Sound System B.E.S.S (currently in build and shown below) will directly ask the question … can you make a very high quality Hifi speaker using PA drive units?!

No automatic alt text available.

Thanks for reading and if you have any comments, please just send me an email:

Ceri Thomas
Code Acoustics
info@code-acoustics.com

4 Replies to “What can Hifi learn from PA? (Pt.3)”

  1. Interesting read, I am presently using a small stereo PA system (Peavey 2-way, 150w) for my hi-fi which I find better than my bookshelf speakers (Technics, die cast aluminium, 2-way, 75w)

    However, for many, many years, my main drivers were 1960’s 2 way, 30, or 40w? (Celestions) due to the weaker amplification at the time; these had a much higher EMF sensitivity – the higher efficiency, and pressure wave as described.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Ian, thanks for taking the time to have a read 🙂 I think a lot of people (once they’ve heard both efficient and inefficient speakers) would say the more efficient speakers sound more dynamic and engaging, so I’m not surprised your prefer your small PA speakers. Also, give me a large diameter bass driver over a small one any day of the week 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s